Typically, Nintendo is seen as a firm that exerts absolute authority over its products. This holistic approach ensures that its iconic franchises, like Mario, remain within its tight grip. Companies with this level of creative control are few and far between, putting Nintendo in a league with behemoths like Disney.
Yet, a single property stands as a notable deviation. Pokémon is possibly Nintendo's most valuable property. Some estimates, though difficult to verify, suggest it is the top-earning media franchise of all time. This wealth comes from omnipresent products, video game sales, and a thriving trading card enterprise. Unexpectedly, Nintendo does not fully control the Pokémon universe.
Nintendo handles the distribution of the flagship Pokémon titles, yet the development work is performed by the outside firm Game Freak. Jointly with Game Freak and Creatures Inc. (the company behind the trading card game), Nintendo co-owns The Pokémon Company. This entity oversees the global merchandising empire that generates billions. Even, the enormous hit Pokémon Go was developed and launched by external studios under a license from The Pokémon Company, functioning at a significant distance from Nintendo's immediate oversight.
A Precedent of Outside Inspiration
This setup might appear unthinkable for a firm renowned for its control-freakery. However, Pokémon was not the initial time an outside title drove Nintendo's fortunes.
In 1989, Nintendo released the revolutionary Game Boy. But, its internal teams had not yet found the ideal game for it. The solution came from outside: Tetris. Nintendo's fierce pursuit to secure the licensing for the Game Boy port of Tetris is legendary in the gaming world. Tetris enabled Nintendo to create and dominate the handheld gaming arena for decades. This portable division provided vital support during difficult times for its console business and ultimately culminated in the versatile Switch.
Despite superb adaptations of its own series, a truly innovative handheld concept was not conceived in-house. Rather, that spark originated with ex- game journalist Satoshi Tajiri, creator of Game Freak. After learning that Game Boys could be connected via a Link Cable, he imagined trading digital creatures, drawing from his youthful experiences of catching bugs.
Game Freak pitched the concept to Nintendo, which quickly embraced it. However, it required a long time for Pocket Monsters to develop into the sprawling role-playing game released in 1996. A few years passed before the titles, alongside a trading card game and an anime, exploded into a worldwide phenomenon. Pokémon extended the life of the Game Boy deep into its lengthy run and essentially secured Nintendo's economic security.
Why Didn't Buy It All?
One might question why Nintendo didn't try to own Pokémon outright as its worth soared. A more aggressive firm would have probably aimed a total takeover. Instead, the tripartite partnership between Nintendo, Game Freak, and Creatures was established as early as 1998. This evolved into The Pokémon Company, which now handles the global franchise.
This model is not completely alien to Nintendo. But, Pokémon's success was unprecedented. Why then not grab the whole pie? Perhaps the original minds behind Pokémon declined to give up full ownership. It is also possible that Nintendo's executives, from the stern Hiroshi Yamauchi to the shrewd Satoru Iwata, made a conscious decision not to pursue full ownership.
The Advantages of Distance
This structure may have been a surprisingly brilliant move. Would Nintendo have sanctioned the vast range of licensed goods or dived into the card market with such abandon? The Pokémon Company, operating with a degree of autonomy, could execute a rapacious strategy to claim global attention and spending.
This distance enabled Nintendo to enjoy the monetary rewards while staying relatively shielded from the periodic controversies related to the brand. When panic emerged about the card game's impact, the focus was directed away from Nintendo. Also, the sometimes variable reception of recent Game Freak games is a reputational price largely borne by The Pokémon Company, not Nintendo itself.
A Lasting Partnership
Perhaps this unique relationship with Pokémon is perfectly Nintendo after all. The firm is renowned for not fixing what isn't broken.|Nintendo typically avoids unnecessary